Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Week 5 Post

The Piltdown hoax started in the early 1900s in Piltdown, East Sussex.  The importance of the discovery of an ancient primate in England was looked to as an older remain than that was found in France and Germany.  The Piltdown man was found by Charles Dawson.  The hoax was discovered by scientists after World War II when they used radioactive dating to date the jawbone.  They measured the levels of fluoride in the bone and looked at it under a more powerful microscope.  The scientists found that the bone was actually only about a century old.  The microscope analysis discovered that the teeth were filed down to be as flat as they appeared.  The actual jaw bone belonged to a female orangutan.  The revelation made sense with the discoveries of human remains in other parts of the world.  If the Piltdown man was true then he would be way more evolved for his time than other human beings in other parts of the world.
The faults of humans make a great deal of errors.  The reasons behind Dawson’s actions were completely unethical.  He may have just wanted the fame of discovering a new step in the human evolution.  These faults negatively impact the scientific process because they circumvent necessary rules and procedures such as not fabricating evidence.
The parts of the scientific process that were positive impacts was the testing of evidence.  The scientific community could have just accepted the jawbone as actually being a part of human evolution, but about forty years after it was discovered, scientists tested it and discovered its falsehood.  The radioactive dating and microscope work were instrumental in discovering the falseness.
I do not think that it is possible to remove the “human” factor in science because human beings are what drive scientific progress.  The imperfect beings can sometimes make false finds but those are not harmful if they are quickly solved.  For the hundreds of false scientific claims produced (that are later refuted), having just one true claim that betters the life of human beings is worth it.  I would not remove the human factor.

A life lesson one can take away from this is to not trust every source of information you receive from people who claim to be knowledgeable.  Discoveries and claims should be taken with a grain of salt before they are verified.

5 comments:

  1. Great summary of the Piltdown hoax! I definitely agree with you that it is not possible to remove the human factor from science. I like ta]hat you stated "... human beings are what drive scientific progress". couldn't be more true and very well stated. Really enjoyed reading your post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you. Discoveries should be checked and checked again until they are verified, to be released as a a true scientific discovery. I also agree that the human factor should not be taken out. Humans are the inspiration of creativity and curiosity. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. In your synopsis, you jump straight from the discovery by Dawson to the uncovering of the hoax. This leaves out a lot of information and forty years of scientific discovery! More detail should have been provided. Who was involved besides Dawson? What bones were found and when? How was the discovery received by the scientific community? I like your reference to France and Germany, but this needed more explanation. Specifically what kind of dating techniques were used to uncover the hoax and when did this happen? By whom?

    With regard to significance, it was argued at the time that Piltdown was older than than the hominids in France and Germany, but that isn't the scientific significance of the find, which can be described as what Piltdown would have taught us about how humans evolved. Why was the size of the Piltdown cranium relative to the comparatively "primitive" nature of the Piltdown jaw? What theory (a favorite of Arthur Keith's) did Piltdown support?

    With the caveat that we still don't know who the actual culprits in this hoax were, I agree that ambition was a likely fault driving the creation of this hoax. Possibly greed as well. Other than the culprits, can you find fault with anyone else? How about the scientific community? Why did they accept this find so readily without proper scrutiny? What might have inspired them (particularly the British scientists) to not do their jobs properly when it came to this particular fossil?

    Very good discussion about scientists coming back and retesting Piltdown after 40 years. Why did they do that? Science requires that old conclusions be re-analyzed when new contradictory evidence comes to light. So what evidence had been discovered that force the re-examination? Can you expand on the technology that helped to provide evidence of the hoax? Who conducted this test?

    "I do not think that it is possible to remove the “human” factor in science because human beings are what drive scientific progress. "

    Perfect. I agree. Science is driven by the innate qualities of humans to question everything around them and to be natural curious about how the world works. Science wouldn't exist without these traits.

    Good life lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great summary, in the beginning you did miss some parts. Charles Dawson also had help from two others.
    I agree with you on the part that it shouldn't be possible to remove human factor in science. I personally don't believe in that and hope one day in the future that is never the case. Overall good job.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with your summary yet it is important to note that this hoax was a group effort; several men, it could even be said a whole scientific community, assisted in the cover up of the false discovery. I also tend to agree with your observation that it is probably impossible to eliminate the human element in scientific exploration as it is "innately human"!

    ReplyDelete