Thursday, February 25, 2016

Week 3 Post

1.    Dogs and dolphins have a homologous structure.  The dolphin and dog seem completely unrelated but they must have had a common ancestor in the past to connect the land mammal to the sea mammal.
The homologous trait in both species is the structure of the dog’s leg and the dolphin’s flipper.  Both have similar bone structures and patterns.  The dog’s bone structure is obviously more conducive of walking, running, and jumping while the dolphin’s flipper is designed for swimming. 
The common ancestor was most likely a sea creature, since life began in the oceans.  The ancestor had the same structures because it is the only way for the two species to have such similar bone structures. 
 

2.    Two species with analogous structures are butterflies and eagles.  The insect and the bird have similar traits but do not have them because of a common ancestor.
The analogous trait are the wings that both animals have.  The butterfly and the eagle can fly but they have different structures behind the means.  The bird has a skeletal system that makes the wings function while the insect’s wings are only comprised of membranes and veins. 
These two creatures do not have this trait because of a common ancestor because we know that birds came from reptiles that did not have wings.  This means that the birds did not get their wings from an ancestor so they are not homologous to the butterfly. 


**Images are from google.com

5 comments:

  1. Wow great job explaining the analogous and homologous traits of both! It's always great to know of more organisms with the same traits and different ancestry. All in all I think you did a great job picking the different organisms that pertain to the two different traits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice job on your post. I actually chose the exact same picture for the dolphin, nicely explained and straight-forward.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good description and explanation of your homologous traits.

    "The common ancestor was most likely a sea creature, since life began in the oceans."

    It is true that life began in the oceans but that was billions of years ago. The common ancestor of the dog and the dolphin, their common mammalian ancestor, lived about 400,000 years ago, long after those first sea creatures, and they were most definitely land animals.

    http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2013/02/ancestor-all-placental-mammals-revealed

    "The ancestor had the same structures because it is the only way for the two species to have such similar bone structures. "

    This is circular logic, meaning you are making your evidence dependent upon the fact you are trying to support. The evidence must be independent. We know that the common ancestor possessed these traits because the common ancestor was also a mammal, and by definition, all mammals carry these rudimentary limb shapes.

    Very good description and explanation of your analogous trait, but this was the best part of this section:

    "These two creatures do not have this trait because of a common ancestor because we know that birds came from reptiles that did not have wings. "

    That is excellent logic. Knowing the evolutionary history of birds and bird wings, we know where and how those wings evolved, and they did not arise from the common ancestor with the butterfly, some 100's of millions of years ago. Well done.

    Good images.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "The common ancestor of the dog and the dolphin, their common mammalian ancestor, lived about 400,000 years ago, long after those first sea creatures, and they were most definitely land animals."

      Note error in my dates as I mispoke: The common mammalian ancestor arose about 400,000 years AFTER the die off of the dinosaurs, so about 64 million years ago.

      Delete
  4. I really enjoyed reading your post. Extremely information and easy to comprehend. I really love how for your homologous trait you used an example of a land mammal and a sea mammal, really great way to bring together two commonly known animals. Great job!

    ReplyDelete