Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Week 7 Post

This experience was something that I have never been through before.  Not being able to speak during a conversation was very difficult.  My partner asked me a lot more questions than he would normally ask.  Since I was very limited in what I could ask or communicate, my partner had to guess what I wanted to say most of the time.  Throughout this conversation, my partner had most if not all of the power.  He asked any questions he wanted and changed the topic freely.  I was reduced to only answering questions and, more often than not, not answering questions.  I only conducted this conversation with one other person so I never felt left out.  My partner had most of the power in the conversation because he controlled what we talked about.  He also was the one that had to interpret what I was trying to communicate to him.  He had free will to change whatever I asked him and I could not argue against him.  The culture that uses spoken language has much more of an advantage in communicating complex ideas because of the nature of the medium of communicating.  The speaking culture might feel as if the other culture as being less developed and maybe even less civilized.  A modern situation that can resemble this relationship could be when people have questions about technology. The population that cannot speak would be the ones who only use the technology but do not know how to discuss the way things happen within their technology.  The technology experts can discuss things in a much more complicated manner than the users can.


This experiment was a little bit easier than the previous one.  My partner had an easier time communicating with me.  It was still difficult because I had trouble making sure not to change the tone of my voice by accident.  The lack of body moment was also very difficult because I am usually very animated when I speak to people in terms of my hand and arm movements.  Our non-speech actions are so important for our communication.  The “reading in between the lines” that happens during a conversation occurs through our “signs” and the tone of our voices.  Reading body language is very important because there are many people who are not very vocal in their communications.  Picking up on their body language is the only way for you to figure out what they want to say or do.  A situation where body language does not give you reliable information would be when a person is judging someone with a physical disability.  People with physical disabilities and those who do not have complete control over their bodies would be misjudged if people look at their body language for information. 

2 comments:

  1. Very good discussion on your first experiment and good analysis of the balance of power.

    I agree with your conclusions regarding the communication of complex ideas. Very interesting example of tech people vs. non-tech people. My first impulse was to deny this as both tend to be using the same basic language (usually English) but you are correct that we are really dealing with two distinct languages and one person in the conversation understands it and the other doesn't. There is an imbalance in power as a result, very similar to the situation we find in this experiment. Well done thinking outside the box on this one. I love it when students raise points I had never considered before.

    For your second experiment, I would have liked to have learned more about how your partner responded to this setting. Usually, the partner's response to the lack of body language is the most interesting part of this assignment, with some being so uncomfortable that they get angry or even walk out. Was your partner at all uncomfortable with this experiment? Did you discuss his impressions?

    Let't think beyond body language as an 'amplifier' of sorts for spoken language. What if the body language doesn't match the spoken language? What does that tell you? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce. (And this section on the benefits of reading body language is either missing or not well defined.... I suggest breaking your post up into paragraphs.)

    Can you identify a group that tend to have difficulty reading body language? I don't see this addressed.

    While I agree that those with certain physical disabilities may express body language differently, body language is not something you think about expressing, so even those with disabilities will usually express body language in a somewhat reliable way. It just may be more difficult to read it through the disability. Let's think about when body language may actually mislead or lie to you. Do all cultures use the same system of body language? If you travel to another country, could you trust what you read from their body language?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also had a hard time with part one, it was difficult when open ended questions were being asked and not to mention the lack of ability to change the subject without speaking or writing. Second one for me was much easier, i found the more i concentrated the less it was required to alter my voice or express myselrf using non verbal speech.

    ReplyDelete