Thursday, February 11, 2016

Week 1 Post

Georges Cuvier held a strong opposition to what Darwin believed in.  Cuvier did not accept any theory that involved evolution.  Cuvier is credited with founding vertebrate paleontology as a new area of study.  He did not believe in evolution because of his belief that any organism that has a changing anatomy would not be able to survive.  One of the topics that Cuvier did work on was that of the adaptiveness of traits.  Cuvier did not believe that organisms can adapt very well to different environments just because of the way their traits work.  He did not necessarily believe that animals had the ability to change themselves physiologically to adapt.  Cuvier also did not agree with the claim that “individuals do not evolve, populations do.”  He studied mummified cats and compared them to present day cats and could not find any difference.  This led him to believe that not only do individuals not evolve, populations do not evolve either.  He studied different types of elephants and compared them to an extinct mammoth.  He showed that the elephants (which had different physical attributes) were of different species and that neither had a bone structure comparable with that of the ancient mammoth.  I believe that Darwin could still have developed his theory of natural selection without Cuvier’s work.  Darwin may have analyzed vertebrate paleontology in developing his theory so there is a chance that Cuvier’s work could have influenced Darwin.  Darwin and Cuvier did not agree on the theory of evolution.  The attitudes of the church completely went against what Darwin had theorized.  His claims were looked at as being against creationism, and it was strongly opposed.   

Source:  http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/cuvier.html

1 comment:

  1. Initial suggestion: Help your reader out by breaking your post up into paragraphs, just as you would for any other paper. Difficult to parse out which sections address which parts of the guidelines.

    You spend a lot of time explaining what Cuvier did NOT believe, but you don't explain what he DID support. Yes, he didn't support the concept of evolution, but he had his own work that related to this question of "how did the organisms we see on earth come to be", the same question Darwin is trying to address.

    Cuvier was seeking to explain the presence of organisms in the fossil record that no longer existed among extant organisms without resorting to an answer based upon the idea that organisms adapt and change over time. His answer: Catastrophism, which explained the fossil record as the result of catastrophic events (such as the biblical story of the great flood). Another key question is how did he explained the appearance of new organisms without evolution? He argued that new organisms appeared through independent acts of creation by a supreme being. That meant catastrophism proceeded through repetitive catastrophic events followed by creation events.

    I agree that Cuvier wouldn't have agreed with the issue of "individuals don't evolve, populations do", but then again Cuvier wouldn't have agreed with pretty much every bullet point in the list, correct? Did Cuvier relate positively to any of the bullet points? How about the fact that Cuvier's idea seemed to acknowledge the role of the environment (via catastrophic events) in determining the organisms we see (or don't see) today?

    " I believe that Darwin could still have developed his theory of natural selection without Cuvier’s work."

    I agree. I see Darwin working off Cuvier as a negative influence, with Darwin essentially developing his ideas in opposition to Cuvier. Cuvier was one of many naturalists of that time and was not necessarily crucial to Darwin's work. Not to say he had no influence at all, but just that his influence wasn't key to Darwin.

    For the final section, the church didn't even know about Darwin's work until after he published, and the question itself is about how the church influenced Darwin's decision to publish in the first place. Darwin delayed for more than 20 years before publishing. So what caused his delay? What were his concerns? And how are they related to the influence of the Church during Darwin's time.

    ReplyDelete